All Filters
285 items
My Sticker Storybook: Dance Recital (500+ Reusable Stickers)
Paige Tate & Co
- Regular price
-
$16.99
- Regular price
-
Retro Basket Jelly Bag in Jelly Mint Green
Sun Jellies
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
Patriotic Parade Kitchen Towel
Nola Tawk
- Regular price
-
$18
- Regular price
-
Sugarboo XO Mug Not Fragile Like A Flower Frida Kahlo Quote Mug
Sugarboo
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
Sugarboo Washable Finger Paint Set 6 Colors
Sugarboo
- Regular price
-
$16
- Regular price
-
Sugarboo XO Mug Elvis Quote Mug
Sugarboo
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
Sugarboo Beginner Paint Brush Kit Set of 5
Sugarboo
- Regular price
-
$10
- Regular price
-
Sugarboo Watercolor Edition Little Artist Studio Set
Sugarboo
- Regular price
-
$16
- Regular price
-
Butterflies Beaded Bookmark
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$3.95
- Regular price
-
Tomato Vine Tinned Candle
The Neighborgoods
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Lemon Zest Tinned Candle
The Neighborgoods
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Sweet Fig Tinned Candle
The Neighborgoods
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Fresh Basil Tinned Candle
The Neighborgoods
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Marigold Tea Towel
The Neighborgoods
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Lilac Tea Towel
The Neighborgoods
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Sassy Talkin Lips This Cute Peppermint Lip Balm Tin
Sassy Talkin
- Regular price
-
$6.95
- Regular price
-
Sassy Talkin A Little Bit Dramatic Blue Raspberry Lip Balm Tin
Sassy Talkin
- Regular price
-
$6.95
- Regular price
-
Sassy Talkin Pucker Up Princess Cherry Lip Balm Tin
Sassy Talkin
- Regular price
-
$6.95
- Regular price
-
Water Lilies Journal
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$12.99
- Regular price
-
Stained Glass Tree of Life Journal
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$17.99
- Regular price
-
Navy Blue Thank You Notes
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$10.99
- Regular price
-
Recipe Card Refills Pack
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$7.99
- Regular price
-
Watercolor Treescape Journal
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$17.99
- Regular price
-
Poppies in Bloom Journal
Peter Pauper Press
- Regular price
-
$15.99
- Regular price
-
New Orleans Hurricane Hard Candy in a Glass Bottle
Ms Merita's Hard Candy Slides
- Regular price
-
$18
- Regular price
-
Hand-Painted 6oz Stoneware Swan Shaped Creamer
Creative Co-op
- Regular price
-
$14
- Regular price
-
Cotton & Linen Printed Tea Towel with Flowers in Vase, 3 Available Styles - White/Blue Vase
Creative Co-op
- Regular price
-
$16
- Regular price
-
Cotton & Linen Printed Tea Towel with Flowers in Vase, 3 Available Styles - Gold/Blue Vase
Creative Co-op
- Regular price
-
$16
- Regular price
-
Cotton & Linen Printed Tea Towel with Flowers in Vase, 3 Available Styles - Cream/Black Vase
Creative Co-op
- Regular price
-
$16
- Regular price
-
Debossed Stoneware Dish, 4 Styles (Each One Will Vary)
Creative Co-op
- Regular price
-
$14
- Regular price
-
Mom Floral Heart Mother's Day Ceramic Trinket Tray
Soiree-Sisters
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
Sisters Scallop Ceramic Trinket Tray
Soiree-Sisters
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
Best Teacher Ever Ceramic Trinket Tray
Soiree-Sisters
- Regular price
-
$18
- Regular price
-
Best Mom and Friend Mother's Day Ceramic Trinket Tray
Soiree-Sisters
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
Happy Birthday Ceramic Trinket Tray
Soiree-Sisters
- Regular price
-
$16
- Regular price
-
Present Grace: A 52-Week Devotional for Moms
Paper Peony Press
- Regular price
-
$15
- Regular price
-
Breathe: 40 Days of Devotions and Reflections on Prayer
Paper Peony Press
- Regular price
-
$15
- Regular price
-
Minted Mango Peach Loose Leaf Tea Canister
Teabloom
- Regular price
-
$20
- Regular price
-
White Pomegranate Loose Leaf Tea Canister
Teabloom
- Regular price
-
$22
- Regular price
-
Storybook Birthday Fairy Tale Greeting Card the Art File
Notes & Queries Inc
- Regular price
-
$4.95
- Regular price
-
Between the Blooms 1000 Piece Foil Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$21.99
- Regular price
-
Liberty All You Need is Love 500 Piece Book Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$19.99
- Regular price
-
Joy Laforme Spring Terrace 1000 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$17.99
- Regular price
-
Joyful 1000 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$19.99
- Regular price
-
Michael Storrings Japanese Tea Garden 300 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$13.99
- Regular price
-
Vibrant Seashells 1000 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$17.99
- Regular price
-
Florette 500 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$14.99
- Regular price
-
The Women's Circle
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$24.99
- Regular price
-
Paperblanks Van Gogh's Irises Puzzle 1000pc
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$24.95
- Regular price
-
Paperblanks Madame Butterfly Midi Lined Softcover
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$17.95
- Regular price
-
Paperblanks Flutterbyes Lined Softcover Flexi Midi
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$17.95
- Regular price
-
Paperblanks Diamond Jubilee Lined Hardcover Midi
Chronicle Books
- Regular price
-
$19.95
- Regular price
-
Showing 250 of 285 products
Gifts under $25
Great Gifts Don't Have to Cost a Fortune
Discover a curated selection of gifts under $25 at Little Miss Muffin — thoughtfully chosen pieces that feel anything but budget. From charming children’s toys and playful accessories to beautiful home accents and sweet treats, every item in this collection is proof that the best gifts come from knowing exactly where to shop.
Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, holidays, teacher gifts, stocking stuffers, and every occasion in between — all in stock and ready to give.
- Curated gifts $25 and under — all in stock & ready to ship
- Children’s toys, accessories & playful gifts
- Home accents, candles & lifestyle gifts
- Faith-inspired keepsakes & devotional gifts
- Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, teacher gifts & stocking stuffers
- New arrivals added regularly — check back often!
Big love. Small price. Little Miss Muffin.
